Master UPSC with Drishti's NCERT Course Learn More
This just in:

State PCS


Mains Practice Questions

  • Q. “India’s rise will depend not only on power projection but on norm-setting in the global order.”
    Analyse India’s ability to shape global rules on technology, trade, and climate. (150 words)

    02 Dec, 2025 GS Paper 2 International Relations

    Approach:

    • Introduce the answer by briefing about India’s foreign policy doctrine
    • Delve into India’s ability to shape global rules on technology, trade, and climate with key examples
    • Highlight the Limits to Norm-Setting
    • Conclude suitably.

    Introduction

    The statement signifies a strategic shift in India’s foreign policy doctrine, moving from being a "Rule Taker" to a "Rule Maker." While "power projection" (hard power: military, economy) determines a nation's weight, "norm-setting" (soft/smart power) determines its influence.

    • As India claims the mantle of "Vishwa Bandhu" (Friend of the World), its ability to institutionalize rules in Technology, Trade, and Climate is critical for a multipolar global order.

    Body;

    Technology: Exporting the 'India Stack' Model

    • Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI) as a Global Norm:
      • The Norm: Promoting open-source, interoperable, and scalable public goods (Aadhaar, UPI, COWIN) rather than closed proprietary systems.
      • Success: The G20 New Delhi Declaration formally recognized DPI as a tool for financial inclusion.
        • Nations like Singapore, UAE, and France have adopted or integrated with India's UPI, setting a benchmark for global digital payments.
      • Data Governance: Through its Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023 India is advocating for "Data Sovereignty", the idea that data should empower the citizens who generate it, rather than just foreign corporations.
      • AI Regulation: As the lead chair of the Global Partnership on Artificial Intelligence (GPAI), India advocates for "Responsible AI" that balances innovation with safety, representing the Global South's concerns against Western AI monopolies.

    Trade: The Voice of the Global South

    • Reforming the WTO: India aggressively pushes for the "Permanent Peace Clause" on public stockholding for food security, challenging Western agricultural subsidies.
      • It has successfully normalized the idea that food security for the poor overrides rigid trade dogmas.
    • Countering Non-Tariff Barriers: India is leading the opposition against "Green Protectionism" (e.g., EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism or CBAM).
      • By labeling these as discriminatory, India is shaping the discourse that climate goals should not become trade barriers for developing nations.
    • Inclusion of African Union: By championing the African Union's entry into the G20, India has structurally altered global economic governance to be more inclusive, shifting the norm from a "G7-led" agenda to a "Global South-led" agenda.

    Climate: From Victim to Solution Provider

    • Institutional Leadership:
      • International Solar Alliance (ISA): India created the first treaty-based international organization headquartered in India (Gurugram).
        • It set a global norm that solar energy is a "common good" for the tropical world.
      • Coalition for Disaster Resilient Infrastructure (CDRI): Setting standards for infrastructure that survives climate disasters, critical for small island nations.
    • Lifestyle as a Climate Strategy: Through Mission LiFE (Lifestyle for Environment), India introduced a behavioral norm to the UN, shifting focus from solely government policy to individual "Pro-Planet People" behavior.
    • Common But Differentiated Responsibilities (CBDR): India consistently successfully reinforces the norm that developed nations must pay for their historical emissions, preventing the dilution of this principle in COP summits.

    Critical Analysis: Limits to Norm-Setting

    Constraint Analysis
    Hard Power Gap Norm-setting often follows manufacturing prowess. India’s dependence on China for solar components and active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) weakens its bargaining power in trade and climate negotiations.
    Domestic Contradictions While advocating for open digital borders globally, India practices frequent internet shutdowns domestically, which critics argue undermines its claim to democratic digital leadership.
    Protectionist Image India’s decision to opt out of RCEP (Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership) and frequent tariff hikes label it as "protectionist," reducing its credibility in shaping free trade rules compared to nations like Vietnam.
    Resource Crunch Initiatives like the ISA require deep pockets to fund projects in Africa/Asia. India’s financial capacity is limited compared to China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), limiting the scale of its norms.

    Conclusion

    India has successfully moved beyond being a "balancer" to becoming a "bridge-builder" in the global order. Its success in DPI and Solar Alliance proves it can generate global public goods. The path to becoming a global rule-maker lies in proving that Indian norms deliver prosperity and equity faster than the Western or Chinese alternatives.

    To get PDF version, Please click on "Print PDF" button.

    Print PDF
close
Share Page
images-2
images-2